Southampton must be 'very careful' over finances amid Spygate scandal

Image source, Getty Images

• Published55 minutes ago

Southampton must be "very careful" over their debts and fiscal position after the Spygate scandal which cost them a chance of returning to the Premier League, says football finance expert Kieran Maguire.

Saints were expelled from the Championship play-offs after admitting observing opponents' training sessions and have been deducted four points for the 2026-27 league season.

An independent disciplinary commission found spying on rival clubs, including semi-final play-off opponents Middlesbrough, was authorised by head coach Tonda Eckert and Maguire says missing out on promotion will have both immediate and long-term effects on the club's finances.

"They will have to be very careful as far as the club's existing debts are concerned," Maguire told BBC Radio Solent.

"They owe over £100m to creditors. A lot of that is due to the parent company, which isn't too much to worry about, but what's of greater concern is that at the end of 2025 they owed £99m in unpaid transfer fees, so that will have absorbed a lot of the cash that the club was running on this year."

• 'The Spygate punishment does not fit the crime'

  • Published5 days ago

• Southampton's Eckert authorised spying missions

  • Published6 days ago

He continued: "Next year, instead of getting a minimum of £110m in broadcast money from the Premier League and all the ancillary benefits that brings, they will be into their second and final season of parachute payments. That will be worth around £35m.

"So, you add everything up and this is why it is called the £200m match as far as the [play-off] final is concerned, you get all the additional TV money, you get an extra two years' worth of parachute payments as a minimum and, of course, you get to pit your wits against the elite of English and, arguably, European football as well."

'Legal issues could continue'

Maguire says Southampton could also face legal challenges from other clubs who missed out on a top-six place, as well as their own players.

"I have spoken to some Saints fans - some are being philosophical about it, some are still very angry," he adds. "I think their anger is directed towards the club more than anybody else. And we still don't know where we are in terms of, will there be cases lodged by Wrexham and other clubs who just missed out on the play-offs – could those be directed at Southampton?

"We don't know what the position is in terms of the players who say they might have been denied the right to play in the Premier League.

"You take a look at a footballer's contract. They are highly incentivised towards success and competing at the elite end, so I don't think we have seen the end of legal issues over the course of the summer and it is not the reason why any of us have fallen in love with football.

"I think part of the reason there has been a silence from the club over the past few days is that they will have launched an internal investigation and will be trying to identify just how far up the management chain these events have been authorised or have people been turning a blind eye? Because there will be some very serious financial ramifications for individuals and potentially the club itself."

Could Saints players sue the club?

While Eckert's future remains unclear, it is also unknown what is next for the players who, at one stage, thought they were potentially 90 minutes away from the Premier League.

Maguire says players taking action against their clubs is not unprecedented in other situations but is unclear as to whether any such moves would be successful here.

"There has been legal action taken by players against clubs where they feel they have not been looked after from a medical point of view and therefore denied the ability to play.

"On the back of that you would have to ask, is this a breach? I don't think it is a slam dunk either way," he said.

Related topics

• Championship
• Southampton
• Football